Massage

Reflexology: zones instead of wellness

Reflexology is not a foot massage under a better name. It works a fixed map that assigns every region of the body to a point on the foot, holds each point for 3 to 5 seconds with the thumb, and takes 30 to 60 minutes for both feet. As relaxation it is well tolerated, even in a trial of 385 women with advanced cancer; as a treatment it is unproven, because a 2011 review of 23 randomised trials found no condition for which the evidence convincingly holds.

A map, not a massage

Reflexology and foot massage use the same 26 bones, 33 joints and more than 100 muscles, tendons and ligaments, but they do different things with them. A foot massage works the tissue: it kneads the arch, mobilises the joints and eases the swelling of a long day. Reflexology works a chart that assigns every region of the body to a point on the sole, the sides or the top of the foot, and the therapist presses those points in a fixed order. The pressure is the tool; the map is the method.

The map has a date. In 1917 the American physician William Fitzgerald published his zone therapy, which divided the body into 10 longitudinal zones, 5 on each side, each ending in one toe and one finger. In 1938 the physiotherapist Eunice Ingham moved the work to the feet and drew the charts still in use: toes for the head and neck, ball of the foot for the chest, arch for the abdominal organs, heel for the pelvis and lower back, inner edge for the spine, from the neck at the big toe to the sacrum at the heel.

What the map is not is anatomy. The nerves of the foot run to the spinal cord and the brain, not to the liver or the sinuses, and no pathway from a point on the arch to an organ has ever been shown. The US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health puts it in one sentence: the points are believed to match up with other parts of the body, and this has not been proven. That does not make the session worthless: it is a structured, slow, fairly firm foot treatment that most people find deeply relaxing, and no substitute for the doctor who is meant to look at your liver.

What happens in 45 minutes

A session runs 30 to 60 minutes; 45 is the usual booking. You sit in a reclining chair or lie on a treatment bed with the feet raised, and the therapist opens with 4 questions: clots, diabetes, pregnancy, medication. The feet are cleaned or soaked for about 5 minutes and loosened for another 5. Only then does the chart come out.

The working stroke is the thumb walk, a caterpillar-like creep across each zone, with single points held for 3 to 5 seconds. Both feet are worked, usually alternately, so each gets 15 to 25 minutes. A point that hurts is held for a shorter time, not pressed harder. Pain is not a diagnosis, and a good therapist says that is tender rather than that is your kidney. The last 5 minutes are long strokes and a rest with the feet wrapped in a warm towel.

Afterwards, 4 reactions are common enough to plan for: tiredness, tender soles, a few minutes of light-headedness, and more trips to the toilet that day. None of them means anything was released or flushed; they are what a slow, warm, low-stimulus hour does to most people. Book the evening rather than the lunch break. Privately, Cancer Research UK quotes 35 to 70 GBP for 60 minutes in the UK; in most European and North American cities expect 40 to 80 EUR or 45 to 90 USD. Practitioners usually suggest 6 to 10 weekly sessions. Review after 3 or 4: if nothing has changed in how you sleep or how your feet feel, stop.

What 23 trials say

Reflexology has been tested more often than most spa treatments, so the verdict is clear. A 2009 systematic review found 18 randomised controlled trials, from asthma and back pain to dementia, diabetes, cancer, menopause and multiple sclerosis; 5 were positive, sample sizes were small, and most of the better-designed trials found nothing. The 2011 update by the same group counted 23 trials: 9 high-quality trials were negative and 5 positive, and 8 trials suggested an effect in diabetes, premenstrual syndrome, cancer care, multiple sclerosis, overactive bladder and dementia, each with caveats. The conclusion did not move: the best clinical evidence does not convincingly show reflexology to be an effective treatment for any medical condition.

The largest single trial is the most useful for a client. Funded by the US National Cancer Institute, it randomised 385 women with advanced breast cancer across 13 oncology clinics into reflexology (95 women), simple foot rubbing by an untrained helper (95) and usual care (96), and interviewed them at weeks 5 and 11. The reflexology group reported better physical functioning and less breathlessness than usual care; nausea and pain did not improve; not one adverse event was recorded. Two findings, then: the method is safe even for very ill people, and its measurable benefit sits in comfort and function, not in the disease.

Two more data points close the gap between hope and evidence. A 2018 Cochrane review of manual methods for pain in labour pooled 10 trials with 1,055 women and found trials of massage and warm packs, but not a single trial of reflexology. For irritable bowel syndrome, often promised on studio websites, the US centre states there is too little evidence to reach any conclusion. So: relaxation, yes; a tender point that reveals a weak organ, no.

When to skip it, and what to say first

Because the pressure is firm and local, the exclusions are about the foot and the leg. A suspected clot comes first: throbbing pain or swelling in 1 leg, usually the calf, with skin that is warm, red or darker than the other side, is a reason to see a doctor the same day, not a reflexologist. The risk is higher over 60, after surgery, in pregnancy and the 6 weeks after birth, and after a flight or drive of more than 4 hours. A fresh sprain and fever are common-sense reasons to wait, and Cancer Research UK adds foot ulcers, athlete's foot, a gout attack and a low platelet count to the list of reasons for postponing or asking a doctor first.

Diabetes is a special case rather than a ban. Nerve damage can take away the feeling in the feet, so that you may not notice a pebble in your sock or a blister that later becomes a sore. Pressure has to be lighter, the foot bath no warmer than 32 to 35 degrees Celsius, and any cut or bruise that has not started to heal after a few days belongs with a doctor or a podiatrist. If you take blood thinners, say so: bruises come easier.

Pregnancy is handled by convention rather than by evidence. Many practitioners decline in the first 12 weeks and lighten or leave out the heel and ankle points afterwards, because the chart assigns them to the pelvis. No study shows harm, and none shows the points do anything, but say you are pregnant before the first pressure, not after. In cancer care the same rule of light pressure applies and the therapist should be trained for it; the lymphatic drainage guide explains why a leg that swells after node surgery needs a different hand.

Choosing a practitioner

Almost nowhere is reflexology a protected profession. In the UK, reflexologists do not need to be registered by law; the NHS advises checking that a private therapist is on a register accredited by the Professional Standards Authority. In the US, 46 states and the District of Columbia license massage therapists, but whether a reflexologist needs that licence depends on the state. In Germany it is usually an add-on qualification for physiotherapists and podiatrists, and in most other EU countries anyone may use the title. Training therefore ranges from a weekend to more than a year. Ask.

Four questions sort the good from the rest: does the therapist ask about clots, diabetes, pregnancy and medication before touching you; do they look at the feet and decline or adapt with athlete's foot, an open sore or a swollen calf; do they call a tender point tender rather than a failing organ; and do they quote a price for 45 or 60 minutes rather than a course of 10 you have to buy up front. A therapist who says the session cannot diagnose or cure anything is not underselling. That is the honest version of the method.

What you keep from a good session is 45 minutes of the relaxation response: slower breathing, a lower pulse, warm feet, a quieter head. You can rehearse the breathing part at home with the Breathing Studio, and the full-body massage guide covers the version that works the tissue rather than the chart.

Questions to ask before you book

Frequently asked

How long does a reflexology session take?

30 to 60 minutes, with 45 the usual booking. Both feet are worked, usually alternately, after about 5 minutes of cleaning or soaking and 5 minutes of loosening.

Is the zone map scientifically proven?

No. The chart dates from 1917 and 1938 and is a working convention, not anatomy: the nerves of the foot run to the spinal cord, not to the organs. The US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health states that the claimed links have not been proven.

Does reflexology treat anything?

A 2011 review of 23 randomised trials found 9 high-quality trials negative and 5 positive, and concluded that the evidence does not convincingly show an effect for any medical condition. In a trial of 385 women with advanced breast cancer it improved physical functioning and breathlessness, but not nausea or pain.

Why am I tired afterwards?

Tiredness, tender soles, brief light-headedness and more trips to the toilet are the 4 common reactions to a slow, warm, low-stimulus hour. Nothing has been flushed out; book the evening rather than the lunch break.

Can I have reflexology in pregnancy?

Many practitioners decline in the first 12 weeks and lighten or leave out the heel and ankle points afterwards, because the chart assigns them to the pelvis. No study shows harm, but tell the therapist before the first pressure.

What is the difference between reflexology and a foot massage?

A foot massage works the tissue of the foot, its 26 bones, 33 joints and the muscles around them. Reflexology presses points on a chart in a fixed order, each for 3 to 5 seconds, and the chart, not the tissue, decides where the thumb goes.

Sources

• National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NIH): Reflexology · definition, the unproven zone claim, the National Cancer Institute trial in advanced breast cancer (385 women, no adverse event), multiple sclerosis, irritable bowel syndrome
• Cancer Research UK: Reflexology · session length 30 to 60 minutes, side effects, exclusions (clots, ulcers, athlete's foot, gout, low platelets), 35 to 70 GBP for 60 minutes, registers
• Ernst E, Posadzki P, Lee MS. Reflexology: an update of a systematic review of randomised clinical trials. Maturitas 2011 · 23 RCTs, 9 high-quality negative, 5 positive, conclusion; the 2009 review by the same author covered 18 RCTs
• NHS: Complementary and alternative medicine · complementary therapists do not need to be registered by law in the UK; check for a register accredited by the Professional Standards Authority

Read on

Tools that fit

This guide is for general information. It does not replace medical or professional cosmetic advice or an examination.